vue - Neeya Naana | நீயா நானா 08:17:14-A doctor's reply

1. well said Dr.
2. Hello Doctor, well said
3. My friend, you are hurt by the opinion expressed because you are one of the few ethical doctors with some compassion remaining in heart. Your point of view is 100% right, a doctor as well as the patient can be relaxed once the test reports are normal. But the truth is the cost of medical diagnosis and various tests are being multiple times costly than the fees paid to the doctors, the diagnosis industry is a billion dollar money making industry equal to that of the pharmacy industry. It is for sure a money making business with business targets. And it cannot be denied that the doctors are in financial nexus with medical diagnosis firms like Appolo or Gemini Scans. It gives middle class patients a great pain and bitterness after spending thousands and thousands on diagnosis which shows everything as normal. From their perspective it is like "I have spent thousands of my money for nothing dedected in the tests. Govenment needs to regulate the prices charged by the diagnosis industry. It needs to fixed to the lowest level. You know many patients (inclusive of my mom ) keeps on post poning prescribed medical diagnosis unable to afford the high prices set for various tests. The same CT scan which is done in Appolo for 3800rs is only 500 in another charity run hospital. There can be a difference, but just compare the difference 3800 and 500. My dear compassionate co human, not just the doctors, everything- every service and every commodity essential for life has been unethically commercialised. Home rent, general provisions, Education from LKG to PHD(money is what it matters) legal services( I am a Lawyer, I say from my heart lawyers have become the greatest Money looting criminals).   'Ignore those opinions', keep doing your best to help the poor. To us Doctors are next to God. We trust you that much, we know nothing about medicine and surgery, what you say are like words from holy scriptures to us. Never go against your inner consciousness..! serve the poor..! I too as a lawyer will try to do my best for the poor..! Best of luck...!
4. உங்கள் கருத்தை ஏற்கிறேன் சகோதரரே. ஆனால் உங்களைப் போன்ற எத்தனையோ பல மருத்துவர்கள் தேவையறிந்து மட்டுமே நோயாளியின் நோயின் தன்மையினை வைத்து பரிசோதனைகளை மேற்கொள்கிறார்கள் என்பதை முற்றாக ஏற்கிறேன். ஆனால் யதார்த்தத்தில் சில மருத்துவர்கள் கோபிநாத் குறிப்பிடும் பட்டியலில் இடம் பெறுவர்களாகத்தான் இருக்கிறார்கள். ஒரு சம்பவம் மட்டும் சொல்கிறேன். ஒரு பிரபலமான மருத்துவர் ஒரு பிரபலமான ஸ்கேன் செண்டருக்கு எம்.ஆர்.ஐ எடுக்க பரிந்துரைக்கிறார். ஸ்கேன் எடுக்கப்பட்டுவிட்டது. பரிந்துரை செய்த மருத்துவர் அவசர வேலையாக வெளிநாடு சென்றுவிடுகிறார். அப்போது உறவினர்களின் ஆலோசனையின் பேரில் வேறு ஒரு அதே துறை மருத்துவரை சந்திக்க சென்றபோது அங்கிருந்த ஆண் நர்ஸ் கையிலிருந்த ஸ்கேன் பையை பார்த்தஉடன் யார் எழுதிக் கொடுத்து ஸ்கேன் எடுத்தீர்கள் என்றார். விவரம் சொன்னவுடன் எங்க டாக்டர் வேற டாக்டர் எழுதிக் கொடுத்த ஸ்கேனை பார்க்க மாட்டார். புதிதாக எழுதிக் கொடுப்பார் அதை எடுத்து வாருங்கள் என்றார்- 24 மணி நேரத்திற்கு முன்பாக எடுக்கப்பட்ட ஸ்கேனை பார்க்க மறுக்கும் மருத்துவர்களும் இருக்கிறார்கள் (காரணம் என்னவென்று உங்களுக்கு தெரியாதது அல்ல) இப்படிப்பட்டவர்கள்தான் இதுகுறித்து வருந்தி திருந்வேண்டுமே தவிர தங்களைப் போன்றோர் கவலைப்படாது உங்கள் சேவையைத் தொடரவேண்டும்.
5. Hai praveen sir.. why you are this much emotionally talking. ?? This is advertisement and business world.. only these 2 things go well now.. all these ppl know.. how much these television ppl earning by a show.. its more than 3 lakhs for one second advertisement in vijay tv during prime show like this.. if gopinath says.. sunland oil.. ovaru thuliyulum anandham once during the show.. he will earn that 3 lakhs... only for tat he is conducting the show.. and not to lose his market values n to raise trp.. he is taking such emotional shows... not in any public interest.. can he conduct a show without any ad in vijay tv.. n not telling sunland oil.. rana murukku kambi inbetween the show.. will vijay tv allow this... likewise drs too cant practice their own wish against the hospital rules.. n nothing wrong in it.. bcos drs also have to survive in this same business world...
6. Hello doctor. Unga thanipatta karutha padiva seye yen unga corporate hospital coat pottu vilambaram seiringa (unga ava iva bashayla shona cheiringey?) neenga unga kudumbatharidam idhe expressions body language oda pesvingla? Neenga evlo selavu panni doctor padichingey sir? Unga hospitalla evlo sambalam? Unga hospital evlo laambam pandrangey? I am from france mattrum naan indialey kude treatment eduthirukken. Inge illedha testellam neengey thala valikku edukka soldringey.... Pondichéry le y best doctors are from GH even they pull rich to their petsonal clinics, GH ellam unga alavukku tests edukka sollalye sir... Apo GH doctors diagnostics à ignore pandrangla? French doctors ignor pandrangla? Anna nalla attrealna thalaye!!! Shemama irungo!!
7. Hi Praveen , 
   Where are you studied  ?
8. Dey Praveen, Unaku 101,3XX views ah?? Dont think like all those are your supporters.. Ellam unoda haters than..
   Understand one thing... In Tamilnadu, unna maari athkal irukira varaikum, Doctor sumugam urupadavae padadhu..
9. So sorry i cannot accept this talk. As a doctor u just support 4 doctors only.. doctors are very less at India u all must love n done ur job very well. Yah as u said no body perfect in this world.. u must know doctor career very clean n people trust u all as GOD.. but now days doctors just need money n make it their career as business.. what the point u earn money in bad way n make people suffer?? Doctors are happy on that?
   
   ( i never put blame on all doctors.. just some of doctors doing is career as business.) 
10. Doctors are not GOD. They are also subjected to disparage. Gopinath is doing his duty, he suppose to criticise the circumstances happening. Now the doctors are overacting and advising him and his profession. 
11. Bro... I appreciate ur effort to convey this message in a calm manner...
    
    And i accept that most doctors take cutbacks...
    
    
    But... If the show makers in vijay TV have guts.... Let them do neeya naana show about Indian politicians who swindle crores of tax money......... Instead of harassing doctors knowing that they won't retaliate with rowdism and threats...... Lol
    
    Mr. Gopinath.... If u do that... I will personally make it my life mission to expose all doctors taking cutbacks......
    
    Peaceout
    
    
12. The problem is not testing or even over-testing per se, but the hijacking of the diagnostic process by a substantial section of the medical establishment to fill their own pockets.  Medicine in India functions in a resource and knowledge starved climate complete with poor administrative practices:  lack of certified cost-controlled diagnostic establishments, lack of original research and practice in almost all spheres of medicine, lack of openness and voluntary divulgence of statistical information on the failures and successes of the profession to the general public, lack of courage in standing up to the hospital management and administrative establishments that they represent and a routine lack of providing feedback to the patients and their families, in fact treating them with an indifference bordering on contempt, lack of being completely open about the realities of each case, good, bad, borderline, unknown or beyond one's competence, instead of using it as a get rich quick scheme.  
    
    A major issue is the lack of checks and balances within the medical community.  Doctors being revered as god by a generally blind, unthinking, unscientific, chronically religious, superstitious and ritual-prone public is one thing.  Doctors thinking of themselves as a god, an incarnation of god or a spatio-temporal substitution for god is laughable and demonstrably dangerous.  While I wholeheartedly concede that there are a number of good doctors and even some excellent doctors, that the diagnostic skills are quite good aided by a large population, the profession as a whole has not done enough to police itself and in the process has failed to protect the paying public they claim to serve, but also has failed to protect themselves and the public image of their profession from being tarnished by others doctors and establishments responsible for the predatory climate in their midst.  In this, they deserve a failing grade.
    
    Primum non nocere.
13. y doctor,yaravadhu intha mathri reayala soona udenea oru youtube rply,do u think this are all not happng in medical field,the hospitals are like hotels,if u want super special treatment the charge is high but the value of human life is ?
    most of the doctors are all same only, the senior doctors are giving respect to human life and who have studied in govtmnt college ,pls dont put like this stupid video and make your name popular ,nobody nos who ur but if your commntng gopinath u think that u can imporve ur drp 
14. Try to implement some changes out of this show too!!! Everyone - get 2 visits to family physicians to replace MHC.. tat costs less even if you have to travel to your hometown!!!
15. look at gopinath .. he himself is at a great risk of getting diabetes and hypertension...he has to screen himself first and try to reduce his weight...most of the ppl in tamilnadu are having the risk of getting diabetes due to the dietary habits and sedentary lifestyle...only through awareness, patient education ,and  early diagnosis we can control this ... he can conduct programs on how TASMAC is causing millions to get addicted ..and as a endresult ppl end up selling everything and spent for medical care.. he can focus on sugary drinks like coke , pepsi , sprite which basically are  diabetic drinks as if  u drink daily , it will surely cause diabetes..... varumun kappom... that should be the mantra ... these programs ultimately will cause doubts in the minds of ppl and avoid them from getting early diagnosis and treatment...
16. ya what you said is absolutely rite doctor but still there is some mistakes carelessness is being among the hospitals so what is the reason behind the kid's vision why ?????????? what is the reason to keep the kid in observation ????? can you bring the vision of the kid again? please AGREE there are many more than 50% are MONEY MINDED PLEASE AGREE WITH THAT and DOCTOR'S LIKE YOU PEOPLE ARE VERY FEW WE REALLY NEED SUCH A DOCTOR..................... you are compared to GOD SO DN'T BE A AGENT TO devil 
17. dei inga ulla *****yum aragorai... I have seen the educated(echakalai) calling themeselves public. ivanunga bankkuku povanunga oru chellan kooda ozhunga fillup panna theriyadhu dei edhiruppu therivikkum puratchi nabargaley sariyana ambalaiya iruntha tvla vandhu pesaama oru consumer courtla case file pannunga. I am know these people when they cannot have truth to defend they play caste card. This doctor is very correct athuvum ottu motha kuttrachaattu sollum gopinath amaam naan kekkuren gopinath enna periya *******ya??? summa oru coat pottukittu periya ivan mathiri pesuraan. dei perusa pesuriyee nee sariyana ambalaiya iruntha poi channel kitt keluda. jodi attamgra perula publicla vechu kuthuraan  ipdi thaan nee kalaachaaram kathu kuduppiyaaa? solluda parkkalaam.***** payaley. doctor sir what u said is rite. I think you have great patience keep it up.
18. I had full respect on Gopi but he spoilt it. I know this is tv media and influenced by the production managers and to increase the telecast rate. But.... this is too much. Indian goverment must do something to vijay tv for this unrealistic judgement because Gopi simply look down the doctors and lead blinds to follow him. From the public side, they gave their opinion but Gopi didnt give time and space for some doctors to give their explanations. This is good topic but badly managed. I wish to see Gopi when he comes to my country.
19. He is a celebrity and thousands of people are watching his programme. So he has to be very careful in whatever he says. Doctors know theie job. We are nothing to critised them. According to the problem and symptoms by patients, doctors do some insvestigations to rule out certain notorious disease which may fetal or harmful. It doesnt matter if the results are normal, but it thousand times matter to a patient if the any of result turned out to be abnormal or positive. Doctors do investigations when they suspect something wrong, and they dont do investigations for absolutely normal findings. Lastly, no body is perfect. Try to help others. Tq
20. well said DR.Praveen